The Small Faces' song 'All Or Nothing' is a fascinating tale of a band that could have been massive, but fell short due to a combination of factors. It's a story of talent, hubris, and the challenges of the music industry in the 1960s. Here's why this song and the band's journey are so intriguing.
A Song That Could Have Been a Hit
'All Or Nothing' was a powerful single that showcased the band's potential. It dethroned the Beatles, who were at the peak of their Beatlemania with 'Revolver' and 'Yellow Submarine/Eleanor Rigby'. This achievement was remarkable, especially considering the competition from The Beach Boys' 'God Only Knows'. It seemed like Small Faces were on the cusp of greatness.
However, this success was fleeting. The band's manager, Don Arden, was accused of chart-fixing, and the band's relationship with him began to sour. This internal conflict, coupled with the band's inability to capitalize on their success, set the stage for their eventual demise.
The Band's Troubled Waters
Small Faces' journey was riddled with issues. Their manager's controversial tactics and the band's internal tensions took a toll on their financial stability. Despite being one of the biggest-selling groups in the UK, they were making little money. The success of 'All Or Nothing' should have been a turning point, but it was not to be.
The band's switch from Decca to Immediate Records produced a few more hits, but nothing reached the pinnacle of 'All Or Nothing'. Frontman Steve Marriott's frustration with being tagged as a pop act and his desire for more creative freedom led to his departure. This marked the end of the original Small Faces.
A Band's Legacy and Impact
What makes the story of Small Faces and 'All Or Nothing' so captivating is the contrast between their potential and their actual trajectory. They proved they could compete with the biggest names in music, yet they never fully realized their star power. The band's dissolution led to the formation of Faces and Humble Pie, both of which had their own share of challenges.
In my opinion, the tragedy of Small Faces lies in the fact that they were so close to achieving mainstream success. Their talent was undeniable, but the stars simply didn't align. It's a reminder that the music industry is a fickle beast, and sometimes, despite your best efforts, the right opportunities may never present themselves.
